There’s nothing better than getting sucked into a series where you just want to keep reading book after book. But for every series like Girl of Fire and Thorns, where I found the second book to be a huge improvement on the first, there is also a series where the quality dips after the first, or the story goes off in a completely different direction. I read a couple of books recently that, while perfectly fine books, did not live up to their predecessors in my mind.
By Elle Katharine White
I enjoyed the initial book Heartstone (billed as Pride and Prejudice with dragons) earlier this year; however this follow up went in a bit of a different direction and lost my interest.
For a series where the first entry adhered almost completely to the plot points of P&P, the second book takes a hard left and, aside from the characters of the previous book and an occasional “sir,” has no relation to Austen or the Regency whatsoever that I could tell. The closest connection I could make is Northanger Abbey, both involving a visit to a mysterious house of secrets, but since everything that Aliza imagines at Castle Selwyn is actually true, the lesson seems to have been lost.
As much as I wasn’t crazy about the slavish adherence to P&P in the first book, without the Austen connection the sequel lost one of the things that drew me to the series and became just a decent generic fantasy. (I did like that it incorporates further mythological creatures instead.) Another issue is that without the P&P backbone, this story is not as tightly plotted and seemed like it was stretched out to make a trilogy. It takes the entire first half of the book for Aliza and Alastair to get where they are going, which seemed like a very slow start to me.
But as a last note, it does take a serious and mature look at some difficult aspects of married life that I think is great for a YA novel to explore.
Suitors and Sabotage
By Cindy Anstey
This YA Regency intrigue was entertaining but kind of forgettable. I discovered the first two books when I was on a Regency romance kick, and really enjoyed them, but I didn’t really feel anything special about this one. Perhaps the formula is getting old for me? (Though these 3 books are similar, they are more companion novels than a series; there is no overlap in characters and no overarching plotline.)
I think the level of tension and drama was not quite up to the level of the first two books. For comparison, the first book Love, Lies, and Spies begins with the heroine hanging off a cliff; this one starts with a lovely picnic among some scenic ruins. It was also less epic in scope, nothing to do with international espionage or even kidnapping, just some vaguely threatening events.
Overall, I’d give these two sequels 3/5 stars, while I probably would have rated their predecessors around 4 stars. While I enjoyed reading them, I doubt I’ll continue with either series, or ever revisit them in the future. On to better books!
My two biggest gripes were one series that I read years ago called Poison Study. I loved the first book and thought it was really interesting. The next two books, Assassin Study and Magic Study, just were brutal. I thought the main character completely changed and was so soppy and boring. Apparently she wrote more in the series but I didn’t read them.
The second series was one I just read this past spring, called The Reader, The Speaker and The Storyteller. In this instance, I wanted to keep reading to see if they could defeat fate/what was written about their futures, and it was a disappointing ending at the end. I felt like I had wasted time. The first book was definitely the best and the last two, though pretty good, just left me with a bad taste in my mouth.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s so disappointing when this happens, isn’t it? It does feel like a waste of time when the sequels don’t live up to the first.
I actually never made it through the first book of Poison Study lol. A friend had lent it to me, and I only made it a couple chapters, don’t remember why.
Ha you know, when I was trying to find the title, I read the description to Poison Study and didn’t even recognize it! So I wonder if I would like it now? Goodreads shows I read it in 2012 so that was a while ago! But I do remember the extreme disappointment I felt with the next 2 books. Those feelings still haunt me hahaha.
LikeLiked by 1 person