Here there be Spoilers for SW:TFA

So I got to see the movie a second time today, and I enjoyed it once again.

I want to talk a little bit more in-depth now about the things I liked and what I didn’t.

I’ll start at the end: Skellig Michael.  It only appears in one scene, namely the last one of the movie.  You may have surmised that this Irish island, which I visited last summer, is in fact the place where Luke has been hiding.  It looks absolutely beautiful in the movie; they did a little bit of editing, adding (I think?) some stones, and some other islands in the chain (in real life there’s only two total).  They also may have edited out some puffins, because I didn’t see any in the film and they are everywhere on that rock in season.

Puffins everywhere

We already knew that film crews have been back to Skellig Michael to shoot for Episode VIII, so I surmised that it was an important location.  It turned out to be very important indeed.  And very fitting.  The only semi-permanent inhabitants of Skellig Michael were Christian monks who kept seeking more and more remote locations to better commune with God, eventually ending up on the island, appreciating its isolation and austerity.  So it is a perfect place to choose as the spot to which a Jedi Master would exile himself.

I understand the First Order/Republic/Resistance situation better now, but I still think the movie doesn’t do enough to clarify the political situation of the galaxy.  They moved too far in the other direction from the prequels.  I am not very happy with the First Order as antagonists.  Starkiller Base is still a dumb plot point, and lacks any kind of emotional intensity.  Hux’s speech is very heavy-handed.  And Snoke is not only more baffling than mysterious, he’s also completely unnecessary in this movie (remember that in the OT we don’t see the Emperor until Empire Strikes Back).

Kylo Ren is not bad, and I will attribute that to excellent acting by Adam Driver, and a strong parallel to the now-discarded EU storylines about Han and Leia’s kids.  Ren is the analog of Jacen Solo, their oldest son whom Luke trains, but who eventually falls to the dark side, taking the name “Darth Caedus” (thank God they changed that…Kylo Ren is much better).  He kills Luke’s wife, Mara Jade, on his path to galaxial domination.

Jacen has a twin, Jaina, the “Sword of the Jedi” who eventually has to kill her brother to stop him.  Jaina takes after her father, being an excellent pilot and mechanic…sound like anyone we know?  Yeah, Rey reminds me so much of Jaina, even with her looks.  They also seem to be hinting that she has a familial connection with Kylo Ren, so their adversarial relationship may turn even more personal.  I think Jaina especially has always been a fan favorite, so it’s pretty cool to see these doppleganger versions of these two brought into the new Star Wars stories.

Speaking of Jedi fights, I really liked how the lightsaber battles in TFA felt different from either the OT ones or the prequels’.  They had the same kind of energy that the prequels’ had, but without the technique.  And while there was less talking than the OT’s, I think they still managed some character development for Ren, Finn, and Rey, which is a hallmark of a great action scene for me.

There’s so much to say about this movie, so feel free to let loose in the comments.  Let’s talk!

3 thoughts on “Here there be Spoilers for SW:TFA

  1. starwarsanon December 21, 2015 / 10:17 am

    You know what – I seem to be one of the few people who did not mind General Hux’s speech. In fact, I kind of liked it…not so much the words themselves but the acting Gleeson did. This was his one moment to show that he was absolutely batshit crazy and completely in love with the First Order. He is a fanatic and obsessed. And I loved it! (I am going to devote a mini blog post soon to Hux and Ren) I have no idea what he said, haha, so maybe in that sense I agree with everyone else but I just watched his fact and he is a psychopath. So for that, I really liked it because I don’t think we got to see the extent of his craziness in any other scene.

    I did like the way they tied in the EU without being too blatant. People who have read the EU got the nods, but people who didn’t, weren’t left out. I was a little bummed that Kylo Ren’s name was Ben. I don’t think it made sense as Leia never met Obi-Wan as far as we know (though obviously she had great respect for him from what her father told her) and Han Solo thought he was a wack job. It made sense in the EU/Legends to have Ben be Luke’s son, but I wasn’t a huge fan of it in TFA. That said – like you, I did like that they pulled from Jacen Solo for Kylo Ren.

    Do you think Rey is Leia/Han’s daughter or do you think she is Luke’s daughter? Or none? Lots of people think Luke’s daughter, which I’m leaning towards but it would be cool if she was neither and they threw us a curve ball. But I doubt it. I think one of the reasons they picked Ridley is because of how much she looks like a Skywalker.

    I also liked the rawness of the lightsaber fight! It was different and it took me a while to get used to it but the second time I saw it, I enjoyed it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.